It is no secret that The Unbelievers Podcast is based out of The Unbelievable Podcast. For those of you unaware, The Unbelievable Podcast was a paranormal comedy show hosted by Brian Frange and Phoebe Tyers. It lasted from 2015 until 2018. Since 2018, the cast of characters that make up The Unbelievers Podcast have taken the ball and ran with it. The goal: presenting a humorous exploration of the paranormal that doesn’t attempt to completely poke fun at the prospect of the unknown. Our hosts are believers, and they are always willing to suspend their skepticism, but the world of the paranormal is often filled with charlatans and ridiculous characters that are rife for picking apart.

The show makes use of a living, breathing soundboard that grows and grows with each episode. While presenting the wild world of paranormal media, comedic bits and pieces will always catch the ear of your astute Unbelieving hosts. Every strange, mumble mouthed, or innocuous but absurd sounding sound clip is likely to be analyzed and puzzled over by this group- and eventually incorporated into the show via the soundboard. Every episode features a poll which the army of Unbelievers out there are welcomed to comment on – and of course add onto with their votes of “Other,” which often devolves into clips about ejaculating into bowls.